« Again: Religion is Not Science | Main | AOL Listens! »

March 14, 2005
Behind Enemy Lines

Liz and I went to a screening of Behind Enemy Lines as part of the Seattle Jewish Film Festival tonight. Some thoughts...

Wait.. first, a synopsis.

An Israeli police officer and a Palestinian journalist - once friends, now on bitterly divided sides of national conflict - reunite for an emotional journey through Jerusalem and the landscape of the Intifada, as each attempts to convince the other of his own truth. Benny Hernes, a captain in the Israeli police force, first met journalist Adnan Joulani on a peace mission to Japan four years ago, and they formed a surprising and optimistic friendship. In the intervening time, however, a member of Adnan's family has been killed by settlers, and Adnan's frustration rises as he covers the conflict daily as a journalist. Benny has meanwhile become a settler and trains special Israeli forces to combat Palestinian militants. In Dov Gil-Har's moving and compassionate documentary, Benny and Adnan agree to meet again, spending four days traveling to locations that each has chosen to represent his own reality. From the Holocaust Memorial of Yad Vashem and the Temple Mount, to the Jenin refugee camp, Benny and Adnan struggle to find a way past the violence that separates them, and for a moment to see through the other's eyes.

Seattle Jewish Film Festival

The film was excellent, not for it's production or execution, but for presenting a truly unique perspective on the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. Personal, gut-wrenching, and relatively even-handed, it leaves many more questions than it answers, as most good documentaries do.

Of note was the sign on the door to the Cinerama, which alerted patrons that all bags would be subject to search, a chilling reminder of how volatile a subject the film deals with. Also noted: nearly every single person in Seattle's Jewish community seems to know every other. There is a very distinct common culture and style among many American Jewish communities - I was reminded constantly of people I knew growing up in Northwest Baltimore. Finally, the Israeli police officer featured in the film, Benny, wears a t-shirt for the last 20 minutes or so that reads, "FBI - Female Body Inspector" like he's a 16 year old at Daytona Beach in 1987.

As for the meat of the matter, that conflict is... how do you say... a giant fucking mess. It's hard to imagine a peaceful resolution when the beliefs of the two sides are so fundamentally opposed. When each side sees the other as an infidel, an evil presence on their holy soil, what common ground can be reached? Each side displays the exact same stubbornness, ironically born of nearly the same ideas. This is their land, and they will die before they are run off of it.

I have to fall back to my position on this issue, first laid out when I announced my bid for the presidency over 2 years ago: No one gets to live there. It's a basic parenting technique. If you can't share, nobody gets it. The holy land becomes an International Peace City or something; you can go visit, but you can't stay. Go, say your prayers, kiss your wall, buy a nice souvenir, and go home. Don't make me turn this car around.

Trackback

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://slapnose.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/982

Comments

Previous Comments

A first step towards a "peaceful" resolution is slowly happening now as the nationalist moron Ariel Sharon - former staunch supporter of Israeli territorial expansion through "settlements" in the West Bank & Gaza - has changed his tune and is slowly coming around to the idea of a separate Palestinian state.

It's not hard to understand why.

Just compare the birth rates in the "Occupied Territories" to Israel itself - each day many more new muslims are born than new jews.

This is the reason Israel will be forced to bring about a Palestinian state sooner rather than later - it's not mathematically possible for the jews to remain the majority people in Israel if they don't offload Gaza/West Bank into a separate state.

Comments on this post are closed.